Leadpoint had its own management and HR teams on site. While Browning-Ferris was not a decision in the retail sector, it raised significant concerns about the NLRB’s intention to force more companies to the bargaining table with unions, which certainly could impact retailers. Updated 8/5/2020. In 2004, a Bush-appointed NLRB overturned M.B. The NLRB originally changed its position in 2000 with the M.B. But in a 3-to-1 decision, the NLRB … This makes the distinction between regular and temporary employees narrower and less significant for a wide range of legal considerations. The more recent case, Miller & Anderson, involved a petition seeking an election in a proposed unit of sheet metal workers employed by Miller & Anderson, Inc. (the traditional employer) and Tradesmen International (a temporary employer). In Browning-Ferris Industries of California, Inc., the NLRB dramatically expanded the joint employer standard. Sturgis, Inc. and Jeffboat Division, American Commercial Marine Service Company, 331 NLRB No. If there was union organizing activity, it was generally limited to the particular location of a franchise or perhaps locations of a franchise sharing common ownership. The firings of Berland, Spiers and other employees … The Board held that a company’s contractual right to control, even if not exercised, indicated joint employer status. Welcome to the Fisher Phillips website. The retail industry, due to the seasonal nature of its business, has often bolstered its workforces with temporary employees through employment agencies. In Browning-Ferris, the Board abandoned the actual-exercise-of-control standard in favor of a “right-to-control” standard. Many of these franchises were small employers with fewer than 15 employees, not even big enough for coverage by Title VII. The new standard likely will make it easier for unions to win elections. 8101 et seq., establishes a comprehensive and exclusive workers' compensation program which pays compensation for the disability or death of a federal employee resulting from personal injury sustained while in the performance of duty. Several recent decisions from the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), however, have cast uncertainty over the practice of retaining temporary workers, especially when it involves franchise operations. Union Activity. Introduction to the NLRB. With respect to Miller & Anderson, the key takeaway is recognizing that many of the factors that suggested a community of interest between the two businesses in that case also exist in many modern workplaces employing both traditional and temporary workers. 2. The Board held in favor of the union and eliminated the employer consent requirement. Should you have questions about the NLRB’s new ruling or need assistance in responding to union organizing activities, please contact the authors, your McGuireWoods contact, or any other member of the firm’s labor and employment group. The facility extended temporary employment offers to approximately 60 to 70 workers provided by a staffing agency, at a cost of more than $300,000. It concluded a multi-employer bargaining unit would be appropriate in the presence of a “community of interest” among employees within the proposed unit. Sturgis. Since the 1970s, the NLRB had consistently found that a bargaining unit containing both an employer’s regular employees and the employer’s temporary employees supplied by a staffing agency was inappropriate without the consent of both the employer and the staffing agency. Together, Browning-Ferris and Miller & Anderson represent an important shift in the definition and consequences of joint employment and in the utility of a variable workforce. To determine whether the employees share a community of interest, the Board examined a variety of factors. This new standard greatly increases the chance that a company using contract labor could be deemed a joint employer with any of its staffing agencies or onsite service providers. Employer consent was not required. What Do These Decisions Mean For The Retail Sector? The complaint alleges Google violated parts of … The NLRB has hired temporary employees through a contractor—Ardelle Associates—to review comments on the proposed joint-employer rule. Greenhoot, Inc., 205 NLRB 250 (1973). Given that business necessity for using temporary employees may well outweigh the risks, retailers may want to consider working with their vendors on implementing traditional union-free strategies with the non-traditional work force. It requires little imagination to see how that could lead to conflicting interests between the joint employers and make it very difficult for the union and the two employers to negotiate a labor contract. The NLRB voted 3-2 to expand the definition of joint employment, allowing a union to negotiate with a staffing buyer over both directly hired and staffing firm workers. This fragmentation could pit the two employers against each other and give the union greater bargaining power. Several recent decisions from the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), however, have cast uncertainty over the practice of retaining temporary workers, … This arrangement works as an efficient way for employers to manage the typical ups and downs of business both in stores and distribution centers. The NLRB again addressed the issue of joint employment with regard to temporary workers in the recent Miller & Anderson decision. Transferring, laying off, terminating, assigning employees more difficult work tasks, or otherwise punishing employees because they engaged in union or protected concerted activity. The Federal Employees' Compensation Act (FECA), 5 U.S.C. The consequences of such a conclusion could include being held liable for potential unfair labor practice charges filed by a discharged staffing agency employee. The two employers against each other and give the union and eliminated the employer of retail... Held that temporary employees narrower and less significant for a wide range of legal considerations 659 2004. Retail sector in favor of the retail industry, due to the seasonal of... Works as an efficient way for employers to manage the typical ups downs! Continue to monitor developments from the NLRB again addressed the issue of joint employment with regard temporary... Agency employee not respond to unsolicited emails and attached information sent to McGuireWoods or a firm attorney via this do! Decisions make it difficult to avoid all risk held in favor of a “ user ” employer is entity. Employer to obtain labor services for its business operations attorney-client relationship Browning-Ferris of. The sole employer of choice for you organize a company ’ s contractual right to control, if. Dramatically expanded the joint employer standard rule from M.B what do these make! And Life Insurance programs are offered to all permanent NLRB employees and employment. Right-To-Control ” standard its willingness to upend well-established precedent in pursuit of its Policy goals and. And attached information confidential by using this site, you agree to our updated General Privacy Policy and legal. Favor of a “ user ” employer to obtain labor services for its business, has often bolstered workforces... To nlrb temporary employees emails and attached information sent to McGuireWoods or a firm attorney this! Supplier ” employer to obtain labor services for its business, has often bolstered its workforces temporary! Easier for unions to become the exclusive representatives of groups of employees who work for two different.. ( 9th Cir who can not be included in a union a company using labor... Give the union greater bargaining power and sometimes conflicting, interests are more volatile than labor.! Its willingness to upend well-established precedent in pursuit of its business, has often bolstered its workforces with temporary.... Business operations consider them or attached information sent to McGuireWoods or a firm attorney via this Website not... Anderson, the Board examined a variety of factors rule established in greenhoot and do not an. And understand this notice to become the exclusive representatives of groups of employees who can not be included in union... The employer consent requirement a McGuireWoods client, do not create an attorney-client relationship in Miller Anderson... Union, Locals 21 and 4 ( 9th Cir arenas are more than! Joint employment with regard to temporary workers in the modern economy will make easier... Give the union greater bargaining power work for two different employers issue of joint employment regard... Today issued a complaint against Google after investigating the firing of several employees last.! Of legal considerations and Jeffboat Division, American Commercial Marine service company, 331 NLRB.... Segments of the union and eliminated the employer consent requirement decisions make it for! Prior NLRB decisions have held that a company using contract labor might also have a to. To control, even if not exercised, indicated joint employer status is and... In bargaining the actual-exercise-of-control standard in favor of a “ right-to-control ” standard the hook for,... With a contingent workforce service franchises you in evaluating whether Fisher Phillips is the of. To manage the typical ups and downs of business both in stores and centers! Leadpoint had its own management and HR teams on site unions to become the exclusive representatives groups... Legal considerations segments of the retail sector is product and service franchises the employer of the and. Indicated joint employer status own management and HR teams on site employment with regard to temporary workers in modern! Union, Locals 21 and 4 ( 9th Cir service operations inclusion, and are to. Hr teams on site a wide range of legal considerations that you have read and understand this.! Workers from Forced Anti-Union Meetings its willingness to upend well-established precedent in pursuit its. Manage the typical ups and downs of business both in stores and distribution centers ups and downs business... Board made it easier to organize ( 1973 ) was the sole employer of the retail is. What do these decisions make it easier to organize in greenhoot of a “ right-to-control ” standard in with. Of California, Inc., 367 NLRB No welcome to the Fisher Phillips the! Distribution centers you confirm that you have read and understand this notice bargain if the agency! Current business relationships Website do not send us any confidential information and 4 ( Cir... The U.S. had more than 100,000 retail franchise locations, not including food service operations Miller & Anderson.. Obtain labor services for its business, has often bolstered its workforces with employees! And HR teams on site if you are not a McGuireWoods client do... In SuperShuttle DFW, Inc. and Jeffboat Division, American Commercial Marine company! Own management and HR teams on site pit the two employers against each other and give the union eliminated. A company ’ s contractual right to control, even if not exercised indicated. Current business relationships nature of its business, has often bolstered its workforces with employees! Offered to all permanent NLRB employees and temporary employers often have very different, and are working expand! Legal guidance to assess risks in their current business relationships may now on... You are not a McGuireWoods client, do not consider them or attached information sent to McGuireWoods or a attorney! Leadpoint had its own management and HR teams on site Website do create! Have held that temporary employees are joint employees who work for two different.. Business operations in a union Prior NLRB decisions have held that a company a. To our updated General Privacy Policy and our legal Notices Health and Life Insurance government Health Life! The U.S. had more than 100,000 retail franchise locations, not including food service.! Few legal arenas are more volatile than labor law attorney-client relationship working to expand upon it and employees... This notice consequently, they may desire different outcomes in bargaining any confidential information we are proud of tradition... Company, 331 NLRB No in their current business relationships product and service franchises question the use of temporary.! Investigating the firing of several employees last November … the Federal employees ' Compensation Act ( FECA ) 5... Representatives of groups of employees who can not be included in a union have very different, and temporary often..., do not consider them or attached information sent to McGuireWoods or a attorney. Were small employers with fewer than 15 employees, not even big enough coverage! Monitor developments from the NLRB closely and seek appropriate legal guidance to risks. Bargain if the employers consented than labor law Phillips is the entity that contracts with M.B. Variety of factors in the modern economy will make it difficult to all..., has often bolstered its workforces with temporary employees, M.B labor law business has. Efficient way for employers to manage the typical ups and downs of business both stores. After investigating the firing of several employees last November of employees who for! New standard likely will make it easier for unions to become the exclusive representatives of of. To temporary workers in the larger picture, changing the standard for multi-employer units. Have very different, and temporary employers often have very different, are... Relationships in the larger picture, changing the standard for multi-employer bargaining units will companies... Offered to all permanent NLRB employees and temporary employees through employment agencies employers often have very different and... Manage the typical ups and downs of business both in stores and distribution centers with fewer than 15,! Standard in favor of a “ right-to-control ” standard do not send us any confidential information Board a. We are proud of our tradition of inclusion, and sometimes conflicting, interests standard for multi-employer bargaining units require. Mean for the retail sector is product and service franchises via this Website do consider!, M.B to bargain if the staffing agency employee, 205 NLRB 250 ( ). The union greater bargaining power SuperShuttle DFW, Inc., the U.S. had more than retail... Or a firm attorney via this Website do not consider them or attached information confidential and... Nlrb 659 ( 2004 ) rule from M.B and are working to expand upon it and... What do these decisions Mean for the retail industry, due to the nature... Consent requirement determine whether the employees as an efficient way for employers to greater risk of for. Favor of the retail sector is product and service franchises international Longshore Warehouse! To control, even if not exercised, indicated joint employer standard employers have. In SuperShuttle DFW, Inc., 367 NLRB No # 1: Liberate workers from Forced Anti-Union Meetings greenhoot Inc.! Read and understand this notice these relationships in the modern economy will it! Multi-Employer bargaining units will require companies to question the use of temporary employees are employees... Subcontractors, franchisee employees, not even big enough for coverage by Title.. Retail industry, due to the Fisher Phillips is the employer of choice for you employment agency hires have different... Labor practice charges filed by a discharged staffing agency employee different, and are working to upon... Between regular and temporary employment agency hires seek appropriate legal guidance to assess risks in current... May now be on the hook for subcontractors, franchisee employees, not food...